Many Etsy Sellers Close Up Shop Over Site’s New A.I. Policy
Etsy sellers are closing shops after new terms allow the platform and its partners to use their content for AI training, prompting the company to say it will revise the policy.
Velocity
How fast coverage is spreading — measured hourly from article rate × source diversity. How this works →
The brief
Etsy updated its Terms of Use with language scheduled to take effect on December 16 that grants the company and its "third party partners and vendors" the right to use sellers' content to "develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies," according to Engadget and PC Gamer. The clause appears in part 5, section C of the terms and also states that users agree not to assert moral rights or rights of publicity against Etsy for using their content, PC Gamer reported.
Sellers reacted by closing their stores and encouraging others to leave, The New York Times and Cartoon Brew said. Engadget noted that the exodus follows earlier criticism of Etsy for allowing mass-produced and drop-shipped items on a platform meant for handmade goods.
Etsy vice president of operations James Ossman posted a clarification saying the change merely explains how the company already uses AI. "We do not use your content to train AI models designed to copy your original work or replace your creativity," Ossman wrote, according to Engadget and PC Gamer. He listed current uses such as automatic translations of listing descriptions, featuring listings in marketing campaigns, and developing tools that optimize listings and provide stat summaries. Ossman also said Etsy prohibits AI crawlers from scraping listings to train models and that third-party partners include fraud-detection services and services that help buyers discover items off Etsy.
Sellers and observers said Ossman's assurances are not reflected in the binding legal text, which contains no opt-out mechanism and makes AI training on by default, PC Gamer reported. The outlet also noted the irony that Etsy recently banned AI-generated recipes and patterns to build trust.
PC Gamer reported an update Friday that Etsy told The New York Times it intends to revise the policy. Engadget said it remains to be seen whether the clarification can bring sellers back.
Synthesized by PULSE from the headlines below under a strict no-invention contract. ✓ fact-checked: all claims supported by sources Updated 1h ago.
Quick answers
What does the new Etsy terms of use say about AI training?
The updated terms grant Etsy and its third-party partners and vendors the right to use sellers' content to develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies, effective December 16.
How has Etsy responded to the seller backlash?
Etsy VP James Ossman said the policy only clarifies existing AI uses such as translations, marketing, and shop tools, and that the company does not train models to copy or replace sellers' creativity. Etsy also told The New York Times it intends to revise the policy.
Why are sellers closing their shops?
Sellers are leaving because the binding legal language allows their work to be used for AI training by default with no opt-out option, and they say Ossman's assurances are not in the terms of service.
Coverage (7)
- Artists and creators are leaving Etsy in droves over its new AI policy Creative Bloq · 7h ago
- I didn't realize Etsy was selling bridges now PC Gamer · 7h ago
- Etsy Says It Will Not Use Sellers' Content To Train AI After They Revolt Over Policy Changes Engadget · 22h ago
- Etsy faces backlash over including AI model training in new policy update CBC · 22h ago
- Etsy sellers are closing their stores in response to the platform's new AI training policy PC Gamer · 22h ago
- Etsy-dus: Artists Leave The Online Marketplace In Droves After New Terms Allow AI Training On Their Work Cartoon Brew · 22h ago
- Many Etsy Sellers Close Up Shop Over Site’s New A.I. Policy The New York Times · 22h ago
Topics
Related trends
Microsoft patent describes turning idle gaming GPUs into paid AI training hardware
A Microsoft patent describes using idle gaming GPUs for AI training and paying PC owners.
The Beleaguered Chip Sellers Getting Their Revenge on Apple
AI-driven flash memory shortages are shifting bargaining power away from Apple and toward its long-squeezed chip suppliers.
Wanted: Robot-Dog Walkers. $20/Hour.
A San Francisco startup is paying humans $20 an hour to walk robot dogs, sparking widespread international news attention.
Etsy to restrict AI-generated content in effort to combat seller slop
Etsy restricts artificial intelligence content to combat platform slop and rebuild buyer trust.
AI training of copyrighted material not fair use: Third Circuit
A federal appeals court deals a major blow to generative artificial intelligence by ruling that training models on copyrighted work is not fair use.
'Cheat Sellers Have Built a Sprawling, Multi-Billion-Dollar Marketplace' — Activision Reveals Eye-Watering Amounts of Money Behind Video Game Cheats
Activision reveals a multi-billion-dollar cheat marketplace as new studies show half of studios losing money to cheaters.