The CMA Now Has a Another Controversy On Its Hands -
The 2026 CMA Awards faced dual controversies over Sammy Kershaw's initial red carpet exclusion and a complete absence of Black or Brown nominees for the first time since 2017.
Velocity
How fast coverage is spreading — measured hourly from article rate × source diversity. How this works →
The brief
The Country Music Association's 2026 awards cycle generated two distinct controversies, according to Saving Country Music. The first involved veteran artist Sammy Kershaw, who was initially denied access to the red carpet before the CMA apologized and invited him to attend. Kershaw accepted the apology but said the incident exemplified the industry's callous treatment of certain performer cohorts and that underlying concerns remain unresolved.
A second, more systemic controversy emerged when the CMA nominations included no Black or Brown artists, songwriters, or producers for the first time since 2017. The Tennessean reporters Chris Parton and Caché McClay detailed the issue through interviews with performer Rissi Palmer and incoming CMA CEO Brittany Schaffer. The article noted that Black and Brown listeners represent the fastest-rising demographic of country music's new fans, making the regression notable.
Saving Country Music argues The Tennessean's analysis overlooks key eligibility and career factors. Shaboozey's collaboration "Amen" with Jelly Roll was eligible, but his album "The Outlaw Cherie Lee & Other Western Tales" was not. Additionally, Jelly Roll had become polarizing, with left-leaning critics viewing him as "MAGA coded" and right-leaning audiences abandoning him after he made Donald Trump jokes on Jimmy Kimmel Live, making a nomination unlikely.
The article also highlights Jimmie Allen's absence. Allen, the first Black man to win ACM New Male Artist of the Year (2021) and CMA New Artist of the Year (2021), saw his career collapse in June 2023 after his manager accused him of prolonged sexual assault, rape, and harassment in a Variety exposé. Additional allegations followed, and Allen lost all industry representation. Saving Country Music noted in 2023 that "the departure of Jimmie Allen will cause a deeper dilemma for the mainstream country industry" because the industry "won't get credit for Jimmie Allen's numerous trophies, multiple #1's, and the other opportunities he was bestowed. Country will only get credit for the lack of these things moving forward."
The War & Treaty were also mentioned as potential nominees. Their album "The Story of Michael and Tanya" (released June 19) was eligible, but the duo had publicly distanced themselves from mainstream country. In a Rolling Stone feature, Michael Trotter stated, "The War and Treaty, in true nature, we are definitely one-million percent an Americana band. And the country music establishment latched on."
Saving Country Music emphasizes that CMA nominations are determined by the organization's 7,000 voting members, not CMA leadership, though the CMA can launch diversity initiatives. The outlet describes the CMAs as "a lot more honest than the ACMs when it comes to taking a true barometer of voter opinion due to their big and diverse voter base."
Synthesized by PULSE from the headlines below under a strict no-invention contract. ✓ fact-checked: all claims supported by sources Updated 53m ago.
Quick answers
Why were there no Black or Brown nominees at the 2026 CMA Awards?
Saving Country Music attributes the absence to a combination of eligibility issues, career collapses, and artists distancing themselves from mainstream country. Key factors include Jimmie Allen's career ending after sexual assault allegations in 2023, Shaboozey's eligible collaboration with the polarizing Jelly Roll, and The War & Treaty publicly identifying as an Americana act rather than country.
What happened with Sammy Kershaw at the 2026 CMA Awards?
Sammy Kershaw was initially denied access to the red carpet, prompting controversy. The CMA subsequently apologized and invited him to attend. Kershaw accepted the apology but stated the incident exemplified the industry's callous treatment of certain performers and that underlying concerns remain unresolved.
Who decides CMA Award nominations?
CMA nominations are determined by the organization's 7,000 voting members, not by CMA leadership. The CMA can launch diversity initiatives and advocacy work, but the voters ultimately decide the nominees.
Coverage (6)
- The Sammy Kershaw Kerfuffle: How Red Carpets Work, And How They Could Change Billboard · 11h ago
- PICTURES: Rodney Atkins Walks the 2026 CMAs Carpet After Almost Not Getting Invited Taste of Country · 11h ago
- Watch: Sammy Kershaw and Rodney Atkins walk CMA Awards red carpet after controversy The Tennessean · 11h ago
- Sammy Kershaw Gets Standing Ovation at CMA Awards After Initial Red Carpet Snub Yahoo · 11h ago
- Sammy Kershaw and Wife Mendy Make Red Carpet Appearance at 2026 CMA Awards After Controversy Over Snub Us Weekly · 11h ago
- The CMA Now Has a Another Controversy On Its Hands - Saving Country Music · 11h ago
Topics
Related trends
Best Photos From 2026 CMA Awards Red Carpet: Taylor Swift, Lainey Wilson, Megan Moroney & More
Taylor Swift headlines the 60th CMA Awards with a performance packed with visual callbacks to her debut era while country music's biggest names walk the red carpet.
2026 CMA Awards live updates: A look at the top highlights and biggest moments
The 2026 CMA Awards spotlight Ella Langley's rising momentum and Brooks & Dunn's record-setting night in country music's biggest showcase.
Taylor Swift's CMA return after 13 years sparks debate
Taylor Swift returns to the CMA Awards stage after a 13-year absence, igniting industry debate and driving Disney ad revenue.
Sammy Kershaw accepts CMA apology after country stars speak out over red carpet access
Sammy Kershaw will walk the red carpet at the 60th CMA Awards after accepting an invitation following private talks.
Richard Sterban, the Bass Singer for the Oak Ridge Boys, Dies at 83
Richard Sterban, the distinctive bass singer of the legendary country and gospel group The Oak Ridge Boys, has died at 83.
Florida Strawberry Festival releases 2027 concert lineup
The Florida Strawberry Festival has released its 2027 concert lineup for March 4-14 in Plant City.