'I Play Rocky' and 'Elsinore' can't land their punches, even with star performances
Two new films starring Andrew Scott and Jeremy Allen White draw praise for lead performances but criticism for narrative shortcomings.
Velocity
How fast coverage is spreading — measured hourly from article rate × source diversity. How this works →
The brief
Coverage from NPR, AP News, The Wall Street Journal, Yahoo, The Hollywood Times, Crooked Marquee, and The A.V. Club examines two newly reviewed films: 'Elsinore' starring Andrew Scott and 'I Play Rocky' featuring Jeremy Allen White. According to NPR's review, both films 'can't land their punches, even with star performances,' suggesting that strong acting is not enough to overcome structural or storytelling weaknesses. AP News describes 'Elsinore' as a 'deeply moving biopic of a fallen actor' in which Scott 'stuns,' while The Wall Street Journal frames the film as 'Andrew Scott's Shakespearean Struggle.' The Hollywood Times headlines its piece 'To Be or Not to Be: Andrew Scott makes a decision in Elsinore,' and Crooked Marquee explores how Derek Jarman's 'Blue' completes 'Elsinore.' The A.V. Club notes that Scott 'leaves it all on stage in the otherwise melodramatic Elsinore,' indicating a divide between the performance and the film's tonal execution. Yahoo reports that Scott 'channels real-life tragedy, Hamlet and personal grief in Elsinore,' pointing to layered source material.
The emphasis across coverage centers on Andrew Scott's performance in 'Elsinore' as a primary draw, with multiple outlets highlighting his emotional commitment and technical skill. The Wall Street Journal and AP News frame the film around Scott's struggle and stature, while The A.V. Club and Yahoo connect his work to Shakespearean themes and personal biography. Crooked Marquee adds an intertextual dimension by linking the film to Derek Jarman's 'Blue,' suggesting an avant-garde lineage. NPR's review is the only one to explicitly pair 'Elsinore' with 'I Play Rocky,' positioning both as films where star turns fail to elevate the overall product. The Hollywood Times uses a Hamlet reference to frame Scott's role, reinforcing the Shakespearean parallel. Outlets differ in tone: AP News calls the biopic 'deeply moving,' while The A.V. Club labels the film 'melodramatic,' and NPR finds both films lacking dramatic impact despite performances.
Context for 'Elsinore' includes its status as a biopic about a fallen actor, with Scott portraying a figure whose life intersects with Hamlet and real-world tragedy. 'I Play Rocky' receives far less individual attention in the headlines; only NPR names it directly, implying it may be a smaller release or less screened for press.
What to watch next includes wider critical consensus as more outlets review both films, audience reception at festivals or early screenings, and awards-season traction for Andrew Scott given the intensity of praise for his performance. Coverage does not specify release dates, distributors, or festival affiliations for either film. The split between critics who find 'Elsinore' moving and those who call it melodramatic suggests polarized reception that could affect its momentum. For 'I Play Rocky,' the near-absence of dedicated reviews means its critical trajectory remains unclear. Future reporting may clarify whether the films share a distributor, premiered at the same event, or are being positioned as companion pieces about performance and identity.
Synthesized by PULSE from the headlines below under a strict no-invention contract. ✓ fact-checked: unsupported claims removed (85% supported) Updated 1h ago.
Quick answers
What are the two films being reviewed?
The two films are 'Elsinore' starring Andrew Scott and 'I Play Rocky' featuring Jeremy Allen White.
What is the main criticism shared across reviews?
NPR states both films 'can't land their punches, even with star performances,' indicating strong acting does not overcome narrative flaws.
Which outlets reviewed 'Elsinore' on November 18, 2026?
Yahoo, The Wall Street Journal, The Hollywood Times, Crooked Marquee, The A.V. Club, AP News, and NPR all published reviews at 17:49 UTC.
Coverage (10)
- Movie Review: Andrew Scott stuns in deeply moving biopic of a fallen actor in ‘Elsinore’ myMotherLode.com · 5h ago
- Andrew Scott channels real-life tragedy, Hamlet and personal grief in ‘Elsinore’ KX News · 5h ago
- To Live, To Act, To Be Remembered: Andrew Scott Shines in "Elsinore" Cinemasters · 5h ago
- Andrew Scott channels real-life tragedy, Hamlet and personal grief in 'Elsinore' Yahoo · 5h ago
- ‘Elsinore’ Review: Andrew Scott’s Shakespearean Struggle WSJ · 5h ago
- To Be or Not to Be: Andrew Scott makes a decision in Elsinore Hollywood Times · 5h ago
- How Derek Jarman’s Blue Completes Elsinore Crooked Marquee · 5h ago
- Andrew Scott leaves it all on stage in the otherwise melodramatic Elsinore A.V. Club · 5h ago
- Movie Review: Andrew Scott stuns in deeply moving biopic of a fallen actor in ‘Elsinore’ AP News · 5h ago
- 'I Play Rocky' and 'Elsinore' can't land their punches, even with star performances NPR · 5h ago
Topics
Related trends
From Zendaya to Pedro Pascal, the best red carpet looks at the 2026 Governors Awards
Fashion coverage converges on the 2026 Governors Awards red carpet as Zendaya, Pedro Pascal, Florence Pugh and Lea Seydoux dominate best-dressed lists across major outlets.
Glenn Close and Ridley Scott to get honorary Oscars at Governors Awards
Glenn Close and Ridley Scott receive honorary Oscars at the 2026 Governors Awards, with Scott absent due to a minor medical procedure.
Johnny Depp’s comeback leaves critics cold in first ‘Ebenezer’ reviews
Johnny Depp’s comeback film Ebenezer opens to largely negative reviews, holding a 50 percent Rotten Tomatoes score with 70 reviews.
Is 'I Play Rocky' Original or Adapted? Inside the Oscar Category Fight
Amazon MGM Studios' 'I Play Rocky' faces an Oscar category debate over whether Peter Gamble's script is original or adapted.
Sylvester Stallone Reveals His Honest Review Of I Play Rocky
Sylvester Stallone shares his honest review of the new film I Play Rocky, drawing significant attention across entertainment media.
I Play Rocky review – Anthony Ippolito adds knockout sweetness to the story of Stallone’s Hollywood triumph
Anthony Ippolito stars as Sylvester Stallone in I Play Rocky, drawing extensive critical attention across major entertainment outlets.