NYC Council passes ban on 'surveillance pricing' that relies on personal data
New York City Council voted Thursday to ban surveillance pricing, making NYC the second U.S. city to prohibit companies from using personal data to charge different prices.
Velocity
How fast coverage is spreading — measured hourly from article rate × source diversity. How this works →
The brief
The New York City Council on Thursday voted to ban surveillance pricing, joining Maryland, New Jersey, and Connecticut in prohibiting the practice. Mayor Zohran Mamdani is expected to sign the measure, saying in a statement to local media: "New Yorkers' personal data should never be used as a weapon against their own pocketbooks. Our administration will continue working with the council to protect workers, tenants, and consumers and put an end to the scam economy." Surveillance pricing refers to companies monitoring customers and setting prices digitally based on data such as location, income, shopping time, and information gathered through apps and loyalty programs.
The vote comes as Democrats in Washington signal they will target the practice next year. Senator Elizabeth Warren, speaking at a progressive conference Tuesday, urged incoming Democrats to pursue bans on AI surveillance pricing through budget reconciliation or new legislation and "dare President Trump to veto popular reforms." She argued that populist economic policies drove election results and that failing to act would be "a tremendous breach of faith with the people who voted for us." Lindsay Owens, president and CEO of Groundwork Collaborative, said surveillance pricing "sits nicely at the intersection of both overreach in Big Tech and overreach in Washington, but also higher prices."
Groundwork's investigations have helped expose the practice. A year ago, the group released a report showing Instacart charged customers wildly different prices based on who was shopping, with average cost swings adding up to $1,200 per family per year. Instacart stopped its pricing tests after the report generated outrage. Warren and progressive representatives have also demanded answers on McDonald's use of AI pricing. The Federal Trade Commission in October launched an investigation targeting nine companies — Delta, United, JetBlue, Lyft, Uber, DoorDash, Instacart, Target, and Walmart. Regulators believe algorithms might provide opportunities for collusion violating antitrust rules. A 2023 antitrust lawsuit against Realpage, a real estate tool used by landlords to set rents, was settled with $360 million awarded to impacted renters. Missouri Senator Josh Hawley, a Republican, has also called for federal legislation.
Polling commissioned by Groundwork and conducted by Hart Research during early voting and just after Election Day in Georgia, Michigan, North Carolina, Ohio, and Texas found that "cares about and fights for working people and people like me" was the top reason voters chose their Democratic Senate candidate. A statement that "the economy has deeper problems than just high prices for everyday essentials. For too long, the system has favored the wealthy and large corporations at the expense of working families" drew support from 52 percent of all voters and 71 percent of Democratic voters. The statement "Government prioritizes the interests of billionaires, big corporations, and lobbyists instead of fighting for the interests of average Americans" garnered 62 percent of all voters and 84 percent of Democrats.
Synthesized by PULSE from the headlines below under a strict no-invention contract. ✓ fact-checked: all claims supported by sources Updated 1d ago.
Quick answers
What is surveillance pricing?
Surveillance pricing is a practice many companies use to monitor customers and set prices digitally, sometimes charging customers more depending on where they are, how much they make, when they're shopping, and other data gathered on them through their apps and loyalty programs.
Which companies have been investigated for surveillance pricing?
The Federal Trade Commission targeted nine companies — Delta, United, JetBlue, Lyft, Uber, DoorDash, Instacart, Target, and Walmart — in an investigation launched in October. Groundwork Collaborative also investigated Instacart, finding it charged customers wildly different prices based on who was shopping, and Warren joined progressive representatives to demand answers on McDonald's use of AI pricing.
What other jurisdictions have banned surveillance pricing?
Maryland, New Jersey, and Connecticut have banned surveillance pricing. New York City joins them, becoming the second city in the nation to do so.
Coverage (5)
- Surveillance Pricers, Elizabeth Warren Is Coming for You Yahoo · 3d ago
- Corporations shouldn’t be allowed to use Americans' personal data or activity online to charge them more. I'm proud to see the New York City Council is taking action! Now it's time for Congress to pass my One Fair Price Act, which would end surveillance p Forth.News · 3d ago
- New York City expected to become the second city in the nation to ban surveillance pricing Consumers Union · 3d ago
- Uber, Instacart and Target can no longer charge you more based on your data in New York City; Mayor Zohran Mamdani says: New Yorkers’ personal data should never be used as a weapon against… The Times of India · 3d ago
- New York becomes second city to ban surveillance pricing Supermarket News · 3d ago
Topics
Related trends
Zohran Mamdani Launches Two-Day NYC Youth Video Game Design Competition With a Transit Twist Ahead of 'GTA 6' Launch (EXCLUSIVE)
NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani launches a two-day youth game-design competition with a transit theme and $3,000 top prize ahead of the anticipated GTA 6 release.
Democrats May Cap Interest Rates On Credit Cards And Student Loans
Democratic lawmakers are advancing proposals to cap credit card and student loan interest rates, drawing both bipartisan support and sharp criticism from economists and industry groups.
New York City Is Set to Ban Companies From Setting Variable Prices
New York City Council is poised to vote Thursday on legislation banning surveillance pricing, making NYC the first major U.S. city to prohibit algorithmic price discrimination based on consumer data.
Elizabeth Warren is ready to go big against corporate America
US Senator Elizabeth Warren is expected to become chair of the Senate Banking Committee, signaling an aggressive oversight blitz for Wall Street.
A study of dynamic pricing found half the U.S. changes it recorded were decreases
A new study reveals that half of dynamic pricing changes in the U.S. are decreases, amid rising consumer and regulatory anxiety over AI pricing.
New York City Council to question SpaceX official over AI safety
SpaceX agrees to testify before the New York City Council following a subpoena standoff concerning artificial intelligence safety.