Where are all the males? Ancient human fossils reveal a startling mystery
Protein analysis of 20 Homo naledi fossils from South Africa's Rising Star cave system reveals no male-specific markers, suggesting either a female-only burial or a lost Y-chromosome gene.
Velocity
How fast coverage is spreading — measured hourly from article rate × source diversity. How this works →
The brief
Coverage from Science Daily, Nature World News, BBC Wildlife Magazine, and Balkanweb.com reports that researchers analyzing tooth proteins from 20 Homo naledi individuals recovered from South Africa's Rising Star cave system found no evidence of amelogenin-Y, a protein marker typically present in males. The fossils, dated to approximately 300,000 years ago, were discovered in the Dinaledi Chamber, a deep cave compartment accessible only through narrow passages. The absence of the male-specific protein across all 20 specimens has prompted two leading hypotheses: either the chamber served as a deliberate burial ground exclusively for females, or the Homo naledi lineage lost the amelogenin-Y gene through evolutionary processes. The findings were published in a peer-reviewed study examining ancient protein preservation in hominin dental enamel.
The coverage emphasizes the methodological breakthrough of using paleoproteomics — the study of ancient proteins — to determine biological sex in fossil specimens where DNA has degraded beyond recovery. Science Daily and Nature World News detail how enamel proteins survive longer than DNA in the African climate, allowing sex determination in specimens hundreds of thousands of years old. BBC Wildlife Magazine highlights the broader implications for understanding Homo naledi social structure, noting that the species exhibits a mosaic of primitive and derived traits, including a small brain case but human-like hands and feet. Balkanweb.com frames the discovery as a rare glimpse into potential gendered mortuary practices among early hominins, though all outlets caution that the sample size of 20 individuals may not represent the full population.
The context for this discovery traces to the 2013-2014 Rising Star Expedition led by Lee Berger, which recovered over 1,500 fossil elements representing at least 15 individuals — the largest single hominin assemblage in Africa. Homo naledi, formally described in 2015, dates to between 335,000 and 236,000 years ago, overlapping with early Homo sapiens in Africa. The species' deliberate body disposal hypothesis remains contested; some researchers argue the cave's difficult access suggests intentional deposition, while others propose natural accumulation. The new protein data adds a demographic dimension to this debate: if the Dinaledi Chamber contains only females, it would represent the earliest evidence of sex-segregated mortuary behavior in the hominin record.
Researchers plan to expand paleoproteomic analysis to additional Homo naledi specimens from the Lesedi Chamber, a second fossil locality within the Rising Star system discovered in 2017. Coverage indicates that confirming whether the amelogenin-Y absence persists across the broader sample will distinguish between a population-level gene loss and a chamber-specific demographic pattern. Further excavation at Rising Star continues, and the coverage notes that protein preservation in other African cave sites may allow similar sex determination for other Middle Pleistocene hominins, potentially revealing whether sex-segregated disposal practices were widespread or unique to this population.
Synthesized by PULSE from the headlines below under a strict no-invention contract. ✓ fact-checked: all claims supported by sources Updated 5d ago.
Quick answers
What protein marker was missing from the Homo naledi fossils?
Amelogenin-Y, a protein typically found in males and encoded by a gene on the Y chromosome, was absent in all 20 specimens analyzed.
Where were these fossils discovered?
The fossils were recovered from the Dinaledi Chamber in the Rising Star cave system, located in the Cradle of Humankind World Heritage Site near Johannesburg, South Africa.
How old are the Homo naledi fossils?
The fossils date to approximately 300,000 years ago, with the species existing between 335,000 and 236,000 years ago based on previous dating of the cave sediments.
Coverage (4)
- Rare discovery in South Africa, 300-year-old fossils reveal a mystery. Was this cave burial ground just for women? Balkanweb.com · 7d ago
- A mysterious ancient human species has scientists very puzzled BBC Wildlife Magazine · 7d ago
- Homo naledi Tooth Proteins Show No Male Marker in 20 Individuals, Leaving a Female-Only Burial or a Lost Gene Nature World News · 7d ago
- Where are all the males? Ancient human fossils reveal a startling mystery Science Daily · 7d ago
Topics
Related trends
A Gene Inherited From Neanderthals Is Still Shaping Human Brains
New research reveals a Neanderthal-inherited gene variant still reshapes modern human brains, shrinking the occipital lobe while cutting schizophrenia risk.
South Africa shootings: 17 killed in Pietermaritzburg and Pretoria
South Africa reels from two mass shootings on the same day leaving at least 17 dead across Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal provinces.
South Africa’s ANC Is Collapsing. The Far Right Is Rising.
South Africa's November 2026 local elections produced 138 hung councils out of 213 municipalities, nearly doubling the previous count and making coalition governance the new norm.
A newly discovered South African dinosaur was a heavyweight even as a youngster
Palaeontologists have identified a new South African dinosaur species, Nyana rooiwalensis, whose juvenile fossil weighed about 400 kilograms despite still growing.
South Africa’s most successful Olympian Tatjana Smith reveals she’s switching to the Netherlands
South Africa's most decorated Olympian Tatjana Smith announces she will compete for the Netherlands ahead of the 2028 Games.
South Africa local elections: ANC under pressure to reverse decline
South Africa's ruling African National Congress suffered its worst-ever election results, dropping to 31% in local polls.