# NFL midseason grades: 2 teams go from Super Bowl hopes to Fs, while overachieving Giants, Browns receive high praise

> **Open Intelligence Dossier** · First detected: 2026-11-12 11:20 UTC · Category: Sports

## Executive Summary
NFL midseason grades show two teams falling from Super Bowl hopes to Fs while the Giants and Browns earn high praise as overachievers.

## Intelligence Brief
Coverage from The New York Times, USA Today, ESPN, and Yahoo Sports reports on NFL midseason evaluations as teams pass the halfway point of the 2026 season. Yahoo Sports leads with the sharpest contrast: two teams that entered the season with Super Bowl hopes have fallen to F grades, while the New York Giants and Cleveland Browns are singled out as overachieving teams receiving high praise. USA Today’s coverage frames its midseason team grades around two A’s and one F, highlighting the polarized state of the league at the midpoint. The New York Times contributes superlatives and lessons, naming Josh Allen for MVP, examining all-in roster moves, and addressing dashed hopes across the league. ESPN delivers a 2026 NFL midseason report covering questions and stats for all 32 teams entering the second half of the season. The coverage emphasizes a dramatic divergence in team trajectories, with early contenders collapsing and previously overlooked teams exceeding expectations. Josh Allen is positioned as a leading MVP candidate in the Times’ analysis, while teams that made all-in moves face scrutiny over whether those investments have paid off. The Giants and Browns stand out as the season’s positive surprises, though coverage does not specify their exact records or the precise grades assigned to each team. The two teams that dropped from Super Bowl hopes to Fs are not named in the available headlines, nor are the recipients of the two A grades identified by USA Today. Readers should watch how the Giants and Browns sustain their overachieving form into the second half, whether the F-graded teams can avoid further decline, and how Josh Allen’s MVP case develops as the season progresses.

## Multi-Source Evidence Table
| Source Outlet | Headline | Verification URL |
|---|---|---|
| The New York Times | NFL midseason superlatives and lessons: Josh Allen for MVP, all-in moves, dashed hopes - The Athletic | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMimgFBVV95cUxPRDJneVNMZVNwVHdvbVp3bURtWjY5cUE4T1ZBcUhGV2xWWndsRng2UWV1d0JLeU01d0EzMXUzX0NSOUI5R3JIV09fd0tRT1pjS0hSTkdOWU5TOEFBM3JXOXp2ZU0yWmV1U0Fkanh2ZUhCZ19uX1RXbFRWdDg1ZnNTV0c5UXkwci1HVmFHZktqQjdFSEdOLXBUM1Bn?oc=5) |
| USA Today | NFL midseason team grades include two A's and one F | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMinAFBVV95cUxObXVhY2hPRms3UHpsczJHdFlfMUZWZVc3c202QVVoVDNXV1R3ZVNRQmg1dmNyRkQ1dUM4aXE0VTE1b0VMVl91cEJYdHhSRU9iS1djUmprUFVpYWxkaHJXY2VwYUVSRjlqSzA2bFJucjRRQ2Ixc1otQ3dyZjdkazRBQnZ6TGlTSlI4cFRxUjFGNWJ5N0tvZGtSeloxQng?oc=5) |
| ESPN | 2026 NFL midseason report: Questions, stats for all 32 teams entering second half | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMimgFBVV95cUxNWFlPYnh1UEplSGRLME9wMmR4RjhQTy1fbDRCZnU0bHVyb0h1V1hFNWE4cVBPcDFiVWZIUkw3cXlNeTBnVHRwbENrRGxvTjZubWdKYzRJazB1S1hGZGZpYUxib3o5aUxaUGVkR3JGYjJzZzh1ZlhuVFBhcDNvaFI1YlVONmh1X3RoaS1yWTZJMnRORXNVVk9wZDF3?oc=5) |
| Yahoo Sports | NFL midseason grades: 2 teams go from Super Bowl hopes to Fs, while overachieving Giants, Browns receive high praise | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMi-AFBVV95cUxNS1NKa0g0UHpXUDZxS0gteW9BZ0NEZk5icHlnNzVTN0xLNk1VaU1TQUg2OWpERC1jNWlkNF9sVG5SSUFxS3VtT1VuYklOckFlaEkzT1FaM3ZMUzcwVDM4SVptMEtRam5oZXBpVXRqMW03dnYyeDYxbUx6RE03T1p5cGx3YzBBOXRaNFNPNVgxS0VpLWhpQ3dIMUR6c0VLeE93LTdmS3NNU3l5UGdhTVp4MURERnRFbGZydERITVVkdDQxXzN1Ti1tOUdMRG1mVnY1ZGZYSW1NX3NhUC1mc0JiWUdmZGY0U0NUQURKOWRIY0RHcnRvZWIyeg?oc=5) |

---
*Canonical Source: https://pulse.byoaiapps.com/trend/2026-11-12/nfl-midseason-grades-2-teams-go-from-super-bowl-hopes-to-fs-while-overachieving*
