How Aristotle helps us unpack the art of deception in Nathan Fielder’s You Can See Everything
Nathan Fielder's three-hour documentary You Can See Everything stages an intimate, unsettling encounter with convicted Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes during her final 34 days before prison, then uses an actor to re-enact their conversations while she serves her sentence.
Velocity
How fast coverage is spreading — measured hourly from article rate × source diversity. How this works →
The brief
Canadian comedian Nathan Fielder co-directs with Lance Oppenheim the feature-length documentary You Can See Everything, which places cameras in the bedroom, bathroom and kitchen of the Southern California beach house where Elizabeth Holmes and her partner Billy Evans spent her last 34 days of freedom before reporting to an 11-year federal prison sentence for wire fraud and conspiracy. The film captures Holmes — who founded Theranos at 19 promising to democratise health care with a finger-prick blood-testing device — in strikingly maternal moments with her newborn daughter Ivy and in tearful postpartum episodes, while she maintains a steadfast, guileless insistence on her innocence: "I'm always being real," she tells Fielder, and "I was just trying to communicate the best I could" when pressed on Theranos claims. Fielder's deadpan questioning grows increasingly desperate as he tries to reconcile what he sees, what Holmes says, and her public personas, leaving the viewer to wonder whether Holmes is sincere or performing sincerity and whether the tactics that fuelled Theranos' rise are on display.
The second half, set in 2025, shifts to Holmes' minimum-security federal prison in Texas, where she is largely unavailable. Fielder hires an actor to stand in for her in re-enactments of their conversations, creating extended therapy-like sessions that dissolve boundaries between actuality and fiction. The film reveals Evans as a controlling figure who holds power of attorney for Holmes and posts on her X account without her knowledge, raising questions about her consent. Fielder, who acknowledges "I'm not the most, like, comforting" presence, stages a final backyard scene before Holmes enters prison in which he asks the couple if they want privacy to have sex for the last time, then cuts to himself alone in his car with music blasting. Close-up zooms generate uncomfortable intimacy, yet Holmes' face remains inscrutable no matter how close the camera gets. The film marks Holmes' first press engagement since 2016 and originated from her and Evans' pitch to A24, with Fielder attached later. Viewers are left dazed, as seeing more does not bring greater understanding.
Synthesized by PULSE from the headlines below under a strict no-invention contract. ✓ fact-checked: all claims supported by sources Updated 5d ago.
Quick answers
What is You Can See Everything and who made it?
You Can See Everything is a three-hour documentary co-directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim that follows Elizabeth Holmes during her final 34 days before prison and then uses an actor to re-enact conversations while she serves her sentence.
What access did the filmmakers have to Elizabeth Holmes?
Cameras were placed in the bedroom, bathroom and kitchen of the beach house where Holmes and Billy Evans stayed for 34 days before she reported to prison; this marks Holmes' first time speaking to the press since 2016.
What role does Billy Evans play in the film?
Evans emerges as a controlling figure who holds power of attorney for Holmes and posts on her X account without her knowledge, with his behaviour taking centre stage in the second half while Holmes is incarcerated.
Coverage (11)
- This film was supposed to expose the truth. Instead, it leaves us in a hall of mirrors SMH.com.au · 7d ago
- Operation Gift Card Marietta Daily Journal · 7d ago
- Can you see everything? Nathan Fielder and Elizabeth Holmes face off in You Can See Everything The Conversation · 7d ago
- Wild film exposes Elizabeth Holmes News.com.au · 7d ago
- Christmas lights in a Ski Town IslanderNews.com · 7d ago
- The movie of the year is finally here The Nightly · 7d ago
- Façade or true belief? Elizabeth Holmes, Nathan Fielder and that cross necklace Religion News Service · 7d ago
- Elizabeth Holmes Almost Fooled Me. I'm a Psychiatrist. Psychology Today · 7d ago
- You Can See Everything is a surreal, brain-melting documentary ABC News & Headlines – Australian Broadcasting Corporation · 7d ago
- We invited three psychologists to watch ‘You Can See Everything,’ and this is what they had to say Boston.com · 7d ago
- How Aristotle helps us unpack the art of deception in Nathan Fielder’s You Can See Everything The Conversation · 7d ago
Topics
Related trends
Nearly two million people are behind bars in the US. How did we get here?
A new Ken Burns-produced PBS documentary series on crime and punishment in America arrives as coverage notes nearly two million people are behind bars in the United States.
Darius Rucker opens up about longtime music career in new documentary
Darius Rucker's new documentary 'They Called Me Hootie' reveals his journey from Hootie & the Blowfish frontman to country music trailblazer.
‘Russell Brand: Open Secret’ Director Says Finding Contributors Wasn’t Easy: ‘There’s Been a Landscape of Fear’
The release of the Netflix documentary Russell Brand: Open Secret prompts widespread critical commentary and detailed coverage.
Billy Evans on Being 'You Can See Everything' Villain: It's Entertainment
Billy Evans speaks out in his first TV interview regarding his villainous portrayal in the project 'You Can See Everything'.
You Can’t See Everything: The Sneaky Problem With the Elizabeth Holmes Documentary
Critics dissect "You Can See Everything," a new Elizabeth Holmes documentary, questioning its framing and what it chooses to reveal or obscure.
Netflix Refuses To Remove Russell Brand Stand-Up Special Featuring Crude Sex Joke
Netflix refuses to remove Russell Brand's comedy special while confirming a new documentary.