# ‘Dawson’s Creek’ Star Kerr Smith on Feeling ‘Isolated’ After Being Told His Character Was Gay: ‘I Never Felt More Like the Fifth Wheel’

> **Open Intelligence Dossier** · First detected: 2026-11-10 13:40 UTC · Category: Entertainment

## Executive Summary
Kerr Smith's new memoir reveals the backlash he faced after his Dawson's Creek character Jack McPhee shared the first gay kiss on American primetime network television in 2000.

## Intelligence Brief
Actor Kerr Smith, now 53, has released his memoir I Don&#039;t Want to Wait: My Life on Dawson&#039;s Creek on November 10, 2026, detailing his experience playing Jack McPhee, one of the first prominent gay teenage characters on American network television. Smith joined the show in its second season in 1998, initially as a love interest for Katie Holmes&#039; Joey Potter. Series creator Kevin Williamson later approached Smith about taking Jack&#039;s storyline in a new direction, leading to the character coming out as gay. In the season three finale &quot;True Love,&quot; which aired on May 24, 2000, Jack shared a kiss with Ethan, played by Adam Kaufman, widely recognized as the first romantic kiss between two men on American primetime network television. Smith told The Guardian, &quot;We did ten takes of it. Ethan was nervous too, no matter what he says now.&quot; The WB network had wanted the scene filmed from across the street with concerns about it appearing too passionate, but showrunner Greg Berlanti insisted the kiss communicate genuine romantic feeling. Following the storyline, protests erupted outside the show&#039;s Wilmington, North Carolina studios. Smith recalled driving past demonstrators and later, while filming The Forsaken in Arizona around 2001, discovered his car vandalized with red graffiti including homophobic slurs. He kept the incident private for years. Smith also revealed production temporarily shut down in 1999 during season three due to cast objections to a Pacey/Jen friends-with-benefits storyline. Joshua Jackson and Michelle Williams pushed back against what they saw as a preposterous and out-of-character plot. Smith&#039;s memoir includes interviews with cast members, writers, producers, and Kevin Williamson, plus a tribute chapter for James Van Der Beek following his death in February 2026. Despite the backlash, Smith says positive fan responses about how Jack&#039;s story helped them understand their sexuality have overwhelmingly outweighed negative experiences.

## Multi-Source Evidence Table
| Source Outlet | Headline | Verification URL |
|---|---|---|
| Yahoo | ‘Dawson’s Creek’ Star Exposes Real-Life Love Triangle That Caused Tension on Set: ‘Worst-Kept Secret’ | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiogFBVV95cUxQb1BIOVhBSXliNFN4YlFObWR0QVlEUkExZEN2RzNUUGRzTkxaSHg2ZjhCLXZ1ZVp2a3p6ZzRmTF9RWkpVT2RyX3FIMXB4ZnBubkJVSE02NkI3S0tMNWRRSmFVamF5MkxXUWh3Y0FxcGhHWG9rdmNpT1hFam1BbEpMZHpKYm1tVklOSTV6anpudDN2Q2JUU25kblpHMW5nckk5bXc?oc=5) |
| Page Six | ‘Dawson’s Creek’ star details James Van Der Beek, Joshua Jackson, Katie Holmes love triangle | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMizgFBVV95cUxQYXNpUFFSTXVOWHNXU0dmSTRYQ2QwTVRtZ3dDVkdiSHhkOXJlTTItLWczT2pVOEZJc3k4V2NJQlN6Ymo0Y3hJNW5MV1JaRUJKcTd5STREOUY3b1FLRzZzR3R4MVZRcm5adlYzQ0RlMlhiaU9ZX3REbzYwakpabmdsVFFkRjI2RmVSaS1NZ2Y3Z2xDSXFFaHBlZUZOdTF1bHVveXZQN3lJRjdFWjREMmJDakt5RDZ0bHlzc0VZRldJWEt1em5tUmJoS0xvZ3dzUQ?oc=5) |
| Yahoo | Kerr Smith reveals the “Dawson’s Creek” storyline that caused production to shut down | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMimgFBVV95cUxNYjh0SUhQaFpxOHRleVhmaVpuVlA2akpYY1o4c3MwcXppMnZ5LTlzUENSWnZiR0ZaenVPQTlLT1RLX0JpeXZtMHc4TWxlTjFBd3NaOXVkWGpqZkpVbDQ5a2lPQzdjS0NtWTh6QndZMmxYbTRpSDBVOXFKZUJRaWk4d0hVQjdJNllObHhXN29LUHZySktyOGM5TG9n?oc=5) |
| Entertainment Weekly | ‘Dawson’s Creek’ book details Joshua Jackson and James Van Der Beek’s on-set tension | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMilgFBVV95cUxPb3JVd2U3YW9rQXBxY1J3LTZHVF9iY043YWpUWVZKa01SMG85SWNhOUFlSFZ6MWc3UGdiVzhmOEl4ZmxIQ0ZrcmdGYUlDUVpPUWR6bVdfd3Y2SlBidkFIQXF6N1dtN2UxR3o2LTg3elRmRTU4S2ZPcHprZzJ6dHhla1g5M1Z0OWlMejdKZ29mWUNUSWNXWUE?oc=5) |
| Yahoo | ‘Dawson’s Creek’ Star Says His Car Was ‘Destroyed’ Over Gay Role | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiqwFBVV95cUxNMmlqLVdGYkhqdDhrY1RhZlFyTk4yaXZUcC1laDVRUlg4dk9aaThEdEYzVHZjNTlBVEhXN09DcXh0U25wdWlQdU42dnJYblZpZnFGNi1XcEhPOGRhRlZscVZlMDcyNW8wRU5FU2JJZ3AxbnlaUkpmbHEtc21mM01rZkdwSmtvN3htRk1RLXBFcmJvQ3V1bkpsN0RiWF93SUg1V2NobTFYWjF2Ym8?oc=5) |
| People.com | Mary-Margaret Humes Made a ‘Mom’ Move to Ease Tensions Between James Van Der Beek and Joshua Jackson | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMixAFBVV95cUxOcklfenZ6eHFBc3hRNHpFdnBpUVBrODROMHh6NmxQT2pyQk43LVBWb0hybC16Mk5HUVFQd1d5aUYwdjVxOG5YRHYzRS1QQzlhamlIMFhBZkJCZmlHbVR3X3c5eEpFTVU2SUV5cUM4WHJlcGlEWkR6cUg2SDFqWnc4MUxyRVVtMnE3NDBrZ0RoOUE5eng0bnVmRHl1NG1rSlFiUzVDcEZfRlNzWXowX0xra0QteThPa00zVWxTZkFkeTlZdElf?oc=5) |
| Yahoo | ‘Dawson’s Creek’ Star Says His Car Was ‘Destroyed’ Over Gay Role | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiqwFBVV95cUxQUDA2QUI0R3E0OTdIekxPT0VYTTc2RmZBeWYxbm9FVnAxZmRvZzJkQzVHSzRfbFNtaGlhcDNESk8wZHB5aktZcDVuR2djZDZPSXBFcEV5Qkx5b0loeUZBUmVQc3dzazhxajNsT0RocGNIX0dzSTMzTThVRi1qQzE2dk94OXJ5QVB0dllSSUd6LW5nVlBEMlAzSVpYYS1yZ0VGQ1pPbFRCYk1kR3M?oc=5) |
| People.com | Kerr Smith Recalls Car ‘Destroyed’ by Homophobic Graffiti Because of Dawson’s Creek Role (Exclusive) | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMijgFBVV95cUxPSmpUSU5Sb0xVOU81ek00elpsSU9uYnlKSFVvZmVGR2tQTWVRT0tRX0xfZWVVUk40NzFxaTlESnIwMUt3aHQ1NVg0NDdkdzY4d0dSUlB0YzNKQ2dCR2lXYmJURVJDQUQtY2NKY0ZFZWJBcjhyQ29TZm11Tk1tT3JLMENCSlNJdENNY1dzak9n?oc=5) |
| People.com | Kerr Smith Wanted to ‘Work Through’ Emotions from Playing Jack in ‘Dawson’s Creek’ Book (Exclusive) | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMigwFBVV95cUxPZ3Z6QklfV0pTZi0zYWN2b0FNeWowdlFwR3RHQU4yRTdJYTh5cmMyeXBfV0FqQnNCNFF1UTJJN0pwWEFLS3ZmOXExYV94SXMxZnBrcGNja2phZTF5UTI0Ui1VMUVlOGV5TGthZW1yT01kZm42WEZtNThxay0wa3Y4LVBnNA?oc=5) |
| PinkNews | ‘I was so nervous’: Kerr Smith on Dawson’s Creek gay kiss backlash and homophobic abuse | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMie0FVX3lxTE1lRXZKM0tVUVhwdThCc1g0X0Z4bDdGNEdSSkg4ZVRCVzk5eklmWno3ejNOWk1VQnBNeUZpWDlPTHlJLW9HQmZISkZINmJZakdGbjFzMzRSWjZqTnF3N2pDd3VVcnM4UkJ6UXBKbUhlc3I1NHRQVENKWWtWYw?oc=5) |
| YOUR EX | Dawson’s Creek Star Kerr Smith Revisits Historic Gay Kiss And Homophobia In New Memoir | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiuwFBVV95cUxPMFlCeDdOUlVBMEU4VWMyUzhPNVJQY0dkdk5XWkJJbWdpSHlyNi1odGlkQk5aRUtyeWtwWmhZd2hPNFF2Ym9pZk04WHRzYVh2dWQ4OFJYM1JJLXR1YWM2NWFzS2FNamk4dElUTTAtVldvQUtuUkNzM2tONFBoVktlM2k2Z2ZwT2dpRXRhb0NzOEF4ZnprYXNzay02a0FlWVlWU3lrZFROQlI5WTcwY3BvNk5zZ1kzMjlqTmxV?oc=5) |
| Entertainment Weekly | Kerr Smith reveals the ‘Dawson’s Creek’ storyline that caused production to shut down | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMingFBVV95cUxQQ3NhbU00YWY0aWtiLVFEQko0TDRJbGZaaEtRdURoSnkxRmJ5clRNejlLTDl0dnY4cmV3bng2UVZxX2xIVlFLTHV2bkwtNFdLZU1kVVRCdkN1czFrcTZhanAyYk9ra3RrczlqS1NRV1VRNVZTVS1wRS1ReUlpWkc2MTBySC1kV012NlRrc0tkYWp1LTFTb0huc1B2Q21FUQ?oc=5) |
| The Guardian | ‘We did 10 takes of it!’ Kerr Smith on Dawson’s Creek and filming US TV’s first gay kiss | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMihwFBVV95cUxNY0VmVVFaLVNKd0VwSE5LSkU5eWE5SERLWDI0dG9fR0VYaG1xQzlaYnFEdTR5QXp5UGFFTGpQQXVWOFFlMzZzeVFMaXQ2eUtJWEpGQURvdjU3V1RxZlFCTUU1S0FuZ0tlM01ycGl5SHRRb2p5VVZKTHQxZWVTbW9heC11N0ZUamM?oc=5) |
| Variety | ‘Dawson’s Creek’ Star Kerr Smith on Feeling ‘Isolated’ After Being Told His Character Was Gay: ‘I Never Felt More Like the Fifth Wheel’ | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMihAFBVV95cUxNVW9iRUNuWjdyM2NLaE1QMXNmSUtBUVd5ajh6aWtBOGxjZmh3QzZ0S25pV212a2dSdThWOFZJMnJ1VXdPWHlNWmJJZko4TUJfMGQ0QVNiRy1WcGdpcWhBVTJtREdFV0hkUmZrdmFzY1lLQzN4MDl3TExnWGUtZDFHVnZfcW0?oc=5) |

---
*Canonical Source: https://pulse.byoaiapps.com/trend/2026-11-10/dawson-s-creek-star-kerr-smith-on-feeling-isolated-after-being-told-his*
