# ‘Wanted’ Review: Rollicking Music and Vocal Riches Sapped by a Runaway Plot

> **Open Intelligence Dossier** · First detected: 2026-11-09 04:20 UTC · Category: Entertainment

## Executive Summary
The new Broadway musical Wanted opened at the James Earl Jones Theatre, offering rollicking music but struggling with plot issues.

## Intelligence Brief
The new musical Wanted has arrived on Broadway at the James Earl Jones Theatre, following a 12-year stop-and-start development process and more than 100 years of real-life family lore. According to Deadline, the show is based on the real-life sisters Mary and Martha Clarke, who set out in 1890s Texas to pass as white and undertake a robbing spree. Their goal was to get the money needed to help their mother, Tallulah, buy the cotton-producing land on which she had toiled for years. Angelica Chéri, an actual descendant of the real Clarke sisters, wrote the book and lyrics, while Ross Baum provided the music. The production stars Solea Pfeiffer and Liisi LaFontaine as Mary and Martha, respectively. Deadline reported that the sisters&#039; motives were pure, taking up arms only after mother Tallulah, played by Ledisi, was cruelly humiliated by a financially strapped white landowner when she offered to purchase the parcel. The crime spree proves instantly beneficial, and romance for both sisters presents itself. Mary falls for the wealthy, white Jesse, played by Bradley Jaden, while Martha begins a flirtation with Jesse&#039;s Black servant Elijah, played by Luke James. Both affairs are extremely risky, and the musical&#039;s song lyrics occasionally remind that lynching is always a looming reality. The Guardian noted that the story is a &quot;mostly true&quot; tale underserved in a production stuffed with superfluous showboating. The potentially invigorating crime spree is reduced to a mere montage, sapping the daring acts of their inherent tension and true sense of risk. Deadline reported that Wanted features a mish-mash score unified by ever-present soaring gospel indulgences that give the vocally talented cast endless opportunity to belt. The production also features Aurelia Williams and Awa Sal Secka as the Black maids Sissy and Flo. Beowulf Boritt designed the unendingly efficient and transmutable barn-frame set, while Stevie Walker-Webb directed the production. Stefania Bulbarella provided video projections, and Emilio Sosa designed the costumes. Wanted is scheduled to run at the James Earl Jones Theatre until March 31, 2027.

## Multi-Source Evidence Table
| Source Outlet | Headline | Verification URL |
|---|---|---|
| Yahoo | Brand-New Broadway Musical Screams 'Tony Winner' at the Top of Its Lungs | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMimwFBVV95cUxNcjBrNnJkUlJfeXcwV0diQTBia1BkN1FHZDJ0blZNRU05cmtNMHhNeFBLTS1zcmpuQ0ZfXzFtOXNxX0RDcXB6RjZLX3lHOVVPNkFMOVQ3MW1aamd0MlFtZ3ZzVzlsWUpIdm1hQ0E1TTJaMU53VVJGNGpnRF81VkxIY3NYbFRsYmFVRW95NTR4S1ktQVlRcW5pdEpEZw?oc=5) |
| Deadline | ‘Wanted’ Broadway Review: Historical Musical Plays With Gospel Truth | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMie0FVX3lxTE5saWZVbG1ULS05Y29FeWI5MWZuV1lOVWFJMDdHcnFZMWYxOURPemYtYmJ2MDVjVlRmblUzWi1rZW5IdU01NndoT1NrbTYxemplQUJad3htOXNHenRDdzdWTmd5NjdxVnpxd2lSNVZZR0NvN21MSVZ3S2Jjcw?oc=5) |
| The Guardian | Wanted review – generic crime musical lacks outlaw grit | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiggFBVV95cUxOSmhtUW5hU3E5VkczbWhVd252ellnTWxwZUd1dXF5cTFlaXZnQTQtUnZkYjEyM1RZRDU0eDFRVTZybGVNVTlqaUJyNFNHSDhSZlcyVmxCN2JoQlFBWkpHby1lSVVpT0NJMEF4QW5YQW41Tk1vZ1ZuMGwyY3FEQzAxVWxn?oc=5) |
| Playbill | Reviews: What Are The Critics Saying About Wanted on Broadway? | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMikwFBVV95cUxPeUo4WEVrb09xVER0Q2U4V1ZnVmtwQ2pPaHE4Q2RBWXBmSml5QzFCOWhJMy1wTjlzUWxZZ1VuaWtlWjVtdHM5dmpmZGlVdkV4RFFtVlFpSk5wLU5XNWdZeUFuaXZFN2FDdjdtZmM5MDB0enkzQlBnVGRHMlk5NWk4MGliTjlab1BFdTNGSlZ5ZG92Uzg?oc=5) |
| The New York Times | ‘Wanted’ Review: Rollicking Music and Vocal Riches Sapped by a Runaway Plot | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMinAFBVV95cUxNek9RY1d0WElyYnc5ZUc4UkR5R1E1U3RRMFRRN2Q4b25Dc2F5eTJISVVqX1JnXzN1RDF2UEJQOUlZeTFMWVhyYk01Ny1JMnAzd2w2ZG9vdllnSUZVQVg5ZlpJLWJMOU5uYW5QTEtodVYyd1IwM3AyYVBYM1ZuMU52bzJ6Ylh0VTMyQkdvbHN2LXpwTHBlUUx0M2V0cGs?oc=5) |

---
*Canonical Source: https://pulse.byoaiapps.com/trend/2026-11-09/wanted-review-rollicking-music-and-vocal-riches-sapped-by-a-runaway-plot*
