# An A.I. Songwriting Experiment: Humans Against the Machine

> **Open Intelligence Dossier** · First detected: 2026-10-03 16:00 UTC · Category: Entertainment

## Executive Summary
A global debate intensifies over AI songwriting as platforms like Suno see massive growth while artists fight for creative control.

## Intelligence Brief
A songwriting experiment titled 'Humans Against the Machine,' reported by The New York Times, is highlighting the friction between human creators and artificial intelligence. This tension manifests as a broader struggle for artist control, which The San Diego Voice & Viewpoint describes as a modern amplification of an old fight that stretches back to the era of Ma Rainey. While some view the technology as a tool for innovation, other perspectives emphasize the risks to professionals. The Express Tribune reports that as machines learn to compose music, human musicians are the ones paying the price for this technological shift. Industry coverage shows a divide between corporate optimism and creative anxiety.


Music Business Worldwide reports that Mikey Shulman describes the AI music platform Suno as being 'far beyond' 2 million subscribers and $300 million in revenue. Shulman further argues that it is 'good' that AI music currently lacks 'firm rules of the road.' Conversely, Campaign India questions whether brands can actually trust AI to handle their music needs. Meanwhile, Todd Edwards provides a contrasting viewpoint in musictech.com, stating he is optimistic about AI in production and expressing frustration toward those who bash technology he considers amazing. Understanding this trend requires looking at the intersection of revenue and regulation. The scale of the industry is expanding rapidly, as evidenced by the financial figures associated with Suno.


However, the lack of established rules mentioned by Shulman creates a vacuum where artist control is contested. The historical context provided by The San Diego Voice & Viewpoint suggests that the current conflict is not entirely new but is instead a technological evolution of longstanding disputes over how music is produced, owned, and distributed in the entertainment sector. Future developments will likely center on whether the 'rules of the road' mentioned by Mikey Shulman are eventually established or if the industry continues to operate without them. Observers are watching to see if the optimism expressed by figures like Todd Edwards will prevail over the concerns regarding musician losses reported by The Express Tribune. Additionally, the outcome of experiments like the one detailed by The New York Times may provide further insight into how human songwriters compare to machine-generated compositions in practical settings.

## Multi-Source Evidence Table
| Source Outlet | Headline | Verification URL |
|---|---|---|
| The San Diego Voice & Viewpoint | From Ma Rainey to AI: New Technology Amplifies an Old Fight over Artist Control | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiZEFVX3lxTE5zcjNITG50QXdfSVdmUzhaNVlIbUZSbW1pSG9hZ1FSaXRIS2taQndXSnBmOFZ4SGtTUWw4WkZPWDVEbE9Lb05jM3ZkaWFmbkZEa3NwLVZEcW96QmxSQ0JDcnp3d3c?oc=5) |
| Campaign India | Can brands trust AI to make their music? | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMipgFBVV95cUxOenZNcTcyQUt6ZmItMnNrdkxsN2FNRmxNdDhlS09xTjB5T3JzY2hQeWtZUnlfWmMyMTRIeGl4YmIzMWlGanlRTVBVTmRVcTh2MS0wNWxSa2lzQ1VqNXhZcU9GZUo0amdOVzNMdDhXcWhRRXhOalA4ZElsX0pTcm9Id3pUN2dld21tRE01dWpDcWg1SUtyQnFPMjRUczlDVExqTkR2c3BB?oc=5) |
| The Express Tribune | When machines learn music, musicians pay the price | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMijwFBVV95cUxNUmVwall3YU5pTDZvV3ZSNHdDQklEME5FQ0pWT3R2bWdzS3BnejNEZ0M1dFRkX1dIYjBPWnhVWmhoWFA2TUFETWE5Zl8tVVB2ZENXS3dxUk91YURJSWxHQVZ6VDQ5NFRrbGptUDExZVVLdXNCemdidEJESjhXUUpoMnpYUTFCSjg2cjZQdzZBc9IBlwFBVV95cUxQQXVETENQX2xOOWRHcnZBaTI3Qnc4RjJVcXdGZTRXNTU5QlFTLXBmdHpjOGhxSXBVZHF4TjdPbm9falhuVk1DaHJST21MRzFBakVzNnlQeG5vNGo3Y195QmQxMzdrbm5vbWlyMXN4d0M0UV9QQzItRXZpUGNwS0U5UDc4V00ycGs2OTlMMkxXRUZJUk1TTjgw?oc=5) |
| musictech.com | “It frustrates me to hear people bashing something that's so amazing”: Todd Edwards is optimistic about AI in music production | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMikwFBVV95cUxPT2VVTlUyRDdKUEY3Ql9vY2RYck94cnpGZ3FHR2tRTmlHa0RfZWJOMWlwbGl3am9iMXJDWnc5Qzd2cHFLaEhNNDN4SUsybTYzSGFHbmNIVXVPT2wzdndjX3lRVEFTTjJ2bGo3dkNqNXVaXzlzV2JWeldqYTBRcVhQNE9Kd2R2TGdqOVp0U0RMRDRxMU0?oc=5) |
| Music Business Worldwide | Suno is ‘far beyond’ 2m subscribers and $300m in revenue, says Mikey Shulman – who argues it’s ‘good’ that AI music has no ‘firm rules of the road’ yet | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMijAJBVV95cUxOa25ldUZQT0NCVmlianRkMnhrZmdGd25qWjdqM3FNVnp4QmtTeC1Gc2p2RFF5SXFJeE9uMi1VZUJQMmtNa296Rld2Y3k0dHdnQUdUdkJzRG9XdXNRWUZzekI4SkUwSXBMVWlXd2hfakpKbGhPd3RPbmdQcmNPZ1BvQVRpNnA5UzVHTnp2dHpaWFp0ckpxVEZCMHpjZlhHWkM4Unc5N2Q5SnNLOFpMTkd1bFVqdWFuQ2JMTTZKdTVPODZ1QTk3UUliOC1NaDJ0eXRrMS1oVGU2X1hneWd3d0tLWG5Ta3ZwaElqZWFseXlBMkxlWDA4c3oxdHQxcDM1YXFza0tsLWhvZTZEYy01?oc=5) |
| The New York Times | An A.I. Songwriting Experiment: Humans Against the Machine | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiiwFBVV95cUxNUGFiQXo4MjJXb09GcEt6RlBQbXZWVWRUQ2cxNkdPT2lLUG9feWNrZWtlU2t4cVNPOWNfa0xNNFZldFEtcEFDR2hlVHRBWFlrTkdGTi1RbmxYUUcxd0pDQl9uRkN6ZWFVUWVoR053aVp6YU94bHVPNTFYRjVDZGQ3TEZBcUIxeHRRTmcw?oc=5) |

---
*Canonical Source: https://pulse.byoaiapps.com/trend/2026-10-03/an-a-i-songwriting-experiment-humans-against-the-machine*